Competency
Evaluate and revise ethical issues in visual media communication to improve awareness of social perceptions.
Instructions
You are the campaign manager for a well known environmental outreach organization. The current campaign is to bring awareness to the organization's Ohio River Clean-Up Project. As the manager, one of your tasks is to review all content and visuals used by the campaign. You actively evaluate and revise any ethical issues that may be detrimental to the project, your organization, or society in general.
As you meet with one of the campaign designers, you identify several ethical problems with the new poster he has created. His poster includes the following elements:
- The poster image shows a group of poor, urban, African-American children playing alongside the Ohio River.
- The poster text states: "Let's help them clean up."
- The poster has several overlaid images in the corner of a few celebrities, which gives the impression of celebrity endorsement.
- There are no sources acknowledged anywhere on the poster.
- The poster has been digitally altered to make the African American children appear thinner, darker, and dirtier.
Since you are flying out to a campaign meeting in one hour, you ask this campaign designer to hold this poster and wait for your video review.
You plan to take time tomorrow to create a seven minute or less video analysis. Using screen share, you can present the poster image visually and verbally instruct this designer how to correct several ethical visual issues. You realize you will not only have to identify the ethical visual issues and explain how to revise and change them, but you will also need to clearly describe to him the effect these unethical media issues will have on society.
After you make your video, you will upload it to YouTube to be sure he views it before this detrimental poster is published.
Note: You may use any visual and audio screen sharing tool to make the videos; if you do not have a preferred tool, an Internet search will provide a number of free versions to choose from.
Grading Rubric
F
F
C
B
A
0
1
2
3
4
Did not Submit
No Pass
Competence
Proficiency
Mastery
Not Submitted
Submission does not competently analyze the visual stereotypes presented in poster and may not discuss a revision option.
Creates video which generally analyzes the visual stereotypes presented in poster and may or may not discuss a revision option.
Creates video which accurately analyzes the visual stereotypes presented in poster and discusses a revision option.
Creates video which thoroughly analyzes the visual stereotypes presented in poster and discusses a revision option.
Not Submitted
Submission does not competently analyze how the ethical issues will affect social perception.
Creates video which generally analyzes how the ethical issues will affect social perception.
Creates video which accurately analyzes how the ethical issues will affect social perception.
Creates video which thoroughly analyzes how the ethical issues will affect social perception.
Not Submitted
Submission does not competently analyze the ethical problems of digital alteration in poster.
Creates video which generally analyzes the ethical problems of digital alteration in poster.
Creates video which accurately analyzes the ethical problems of digital alteration in poster.
Creates video which thoroughly analyzes the ethical problems of digital alteration in poster.
Not Submitted
Submission does not competently analyze the ethical problems of using improperly acknowledged images sources in poster.
Creates video which generally analyzes the ethical problems of using improperly acknowledged images sources in poster.
Creates video which accurately analyzes the ethical problems of using improperly acknowledged images sources in poster.
Creates video which thoroughly analyzes the ethical problems of using improperly acknowledged images sources in poster.
Other samples, services and questions:
When you use PaperHelp, you save one valuable — TIME
You can spend it for more important things than paper writing.
